Hiring more workers will not fix a leaky trades workforce
New training programs may bring more people into the trades. Owners still need a plan to train, promote and keep the workers they hire.
Big companies and foundations are putting money into trade schools and apprenticeships. But a larger stream of new applicants will not solve a worker shortage if businesses keep losing the people they already hire.
That is the central point in a recent Contracting Business article by Jamie Gerdsen, a home services operator. He argues that the trades’ talent challenge is less about attracting workers than giving them reasons and ways to build a career.
The numbers in the article show why retention matters. TechForce Foundation estimates the economy needs roughly 240,000 new technicians a year across the sectors it studies, while training programs produce fewer than half that number. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects about 80,000 electrician openings each year through 2034, many to replace workers who leave.
Hiring alone does not close that gap. TechForce found that employers across the sectors it studies hired about 1.18 million technicians in one recent year and lost roughly 1.14 million. The net gain was around 32,000 people, against more than 240,000 openings.
For a small service company, that turnover can hit the schedule and the customer experience. A departing worker takes job knowledge with them, and the next hire needs time to learn the work. Customers may also see a new face at every visit, which can weaken trust.
Build the next step into the job
Gerdsen says the companies that keep workers build ways for them to grow. That can mean moving an apprentice into a technician role, then giving experienced technicians a path to lead jobs or manage people. It also means training managers to coach instead of leaving them to figure it out alone.
A career path does not need to promise a promotion on a fixed date. It should show workers what skills, reliability and responsibility can lead to the next role, and what support they will get along the way. When expectations are clear, workers can see how their effort connects to a future at the company.
The article points to a shift in how people view education. A Pew Research Center survey found that about one in four U.S. adults now consider a four-year degree very or extremely important for getting a well-paying job. Registered apprenticeships have also grown over the past decade, according to the U.S. Department of Labor.
That interest gives service companies a chance to meet potential workers with a real development plan. But a signing bonus is easy for a competitor to match. An apprenticeship, steady coaching and a clear route to more responsibility are harder to copy, the article argues.
Google’s $4 million investment in electrical construction leadership training offers one example of how the industry is putting structure behind development. Construction Owners reports that the program will expand training across project work, from preconstruction and field supervision to commissioning and closeout. Its first expanded cohorts are expected in the second quarter of 2027.
Small operators do not need a large company’s budget to start. They can write down the skills a new worker must learn, pair that worker with an experienced employee, and set regular check-ins. They can also ask each worker what kind of responsibility they want to take on next.
Make one improvement this week
Owners can start with a short review of what happens after the hire. The goal is to find one gap that causes workers to stall, feel unsupported or leave.
- Write a one-page path from entry-level work to the next role, with the skills needed at each step.
- Choose one experienced worker to coach a newer employee, and set a regular time to review progress.
- Ask each employee what training or responsibility would help them stay and grow.
- Train a lead or manager on how to give clear feedback and handle questions before small problems become reasons to quit.
More training programs may help widen the pool of workers. But each business still has to make the job worth staying for. This week, owners can start by showing workers what comes after their first day on the truck.